Skip to content

Ryland Inn: Transforming History and Dining in New Jersey

Mr Local History digs into the history of the Ryland Inn in Whitehouse, New Jersey, on Route 22

. The Ryland Inn: What History Tells Us

What if one of New Jersey’s most famous historic restaurants isn’t quite as old as everyone thinks? For years, the Ryland Inn in Whitehouse Station has proudly traced its beginnings to 1796. It’s a great story, but when you dig into the historical record, things get a little more interesting. Before the fine dining, celebrity chefs, and elegant weddings, this Readington Township landmark was a working farm owned by David Sanderson. And the building’s actual age may surprise you.

Fortunately, three historical researchers left us some valuable clues. In January 2013, Ann Parsekian, Janice Armstrong, and Dennis Bertland prepared a 123-page nomination for the National Register of Historic Places documenting the Whitehouse–Mechanicsville Historic District in Readington Township. Their research explored the community’s early roads, farms, buildings, and the families who helped shape the area.

Among the properties they examined was the old Sanderson residence, identified as Site No. 101. Rather than dating the surviving house to 1796, the researchers placed its construction in the mid-nineteenth century and described its distinctive Gothic Revival and Italianate architecture. Surrounding the house were barns and other farm buildings that told the story of a working agricultural estate.

And that’s where our story really begins. Somewhere between the Sanderson family’s farming years and the Ryman family’s arrival in 1906, this country property began a journey that would eventually transform it into a tearoom in 1928 and the Ryland Inn in 1934. Nearly a century later, its name remains familiar throughout New Jersey, even as the building’s earlier history continues to reveal a few surprises.

For longtime Hunterdon County residents, memories of the Ryland Inn aren’t necessarily about celebrity chefs, expensive wines, or four-star dining. They’re about the bar, the music, the familiar faces, and evenings spent with friends. Before the restaurant became a nationally recognized culinary destination, the Ryland was a comfortable country gathering place where locals and newcomers crossed paths.

1949 advertisement – Ryland Inn
An aerial view of the Ryland Inn in Whitehouse, New Jersey, believed to date from approximately 1940 to 1955. The photograph captures the country inn surrounded by farmland, mature trees, and several outbuildings, long before the property’s modern expansion.

Long before celebrity chefs and elaborate weddings, the Ryland Inn was a family business, and Phyllis Ryman Black was at its heart. Born in the family home that would become the restaurant, she took over its operation in July 1956 when her parents retired. Over the following decades, she helped transform the country inn into one of Hunterdon County’s most respected dining establishments.

By the 1970s, the next generation was joining the business. Her son, Jette Black, entered management in 1972, followed by her son-in-law, Timothy Maxwell, in 1973. Together, they carried forward a family tradition built around hospitality, food, and service.

In April 1980, Phyllis received the International Geneva Association’s Restaurateur of the Year Award, recognizing the Ryland Inn’s excellence. It was a remarkable achievement for a woman who had already made history in 1942 as one of New Jersey’s pioneering female theater managers.

The 1970s-1980s

Picture Whitehouse Station in the 1970s and 1980s. Eastern Hunterdon County was changing as farmland gradually gave way to suburban neighborhoods. Commuters returning from New York City joined longtime residents for a drink or a casual dinner. The Ryland Inn offered a place to unwind, catch up on local gossip, and enjoy an evening out. Food writer Andy Clurfeld, who remembered stopping there between evening assignments, later described the bar as an informal gathering place for commuters, diners, and local journalists.

Phyllis Ryman Black c1980.

For longtime patrons who remember the Ryland Inn’s earlier dining and entertainment years, Phyllis Black represents an important chapter. Before the restaurant became nationally famous, the Ryman family had already built a reputation worth celebrating.

Remembering the Ryland Inn’s Piano Bar Years

For those who remember the piano bar, the music is part of what made the place special. It was an era when entertainment didn’t have to mean a concert or a crowded nightclub. A familiar song, a favorite cocktail, and a room full of conversation could make an ordinary evening memorable.

By 1991, chef Craig Shelton would begin transforming the Ryland Inn into one of New Jersey’s most celebrated restaurants. But for an earlier generation, the memories were less about culinary awards and more about the people who gathered there. Who played the piano? Who tended bar? Who met their future spouse there? Those are the stories that still deserve to be told.

And perhaps that’s the real charm of the old Ryland Inn. Long before it became famous for its food, people remembered it as a place where they simply enjoyed being together.

From Fine Dining to the Wedding Factory: The Ryland Inn’s Next Act

For years, couples went to the Ryland Inn for a romantic dinner. Eventually, it became where couples went to get married. That transformation would forever change one of Hunterdon County’s most famous restaurants.

In 2007, the music stopped at the Ryland Inn. After years as one of New Jersey’s most celebrated restaurants under chef Craig Shelton, extensive water damage and financial troubles forced the historic restaurant to close. A frozen water main brought disaster to the celebrated Ryland Inn in early 2007, flooding its basement with four feet of water and damaging electrical equipment, heating systems, and other essential utilities.

According to The Star-Ledger, executive chef Scott Anderson described a series of complications that forced the restaurant to remain closed for extensive repairs. Under chef and owner Craig Shelton, the Ryland had earned four-star reviews and recognition as one of New Jersey’s finest restaurants. What was initially expected to be a temporary shutdown threatened the future of the historic establishment, disrupting dining, weddings, and private events. The property eventually fell into foreclosure, leaving its future uncertain. The restaurant would not reopen until 2012 under new ownership, marking the end of the celebrated Shelton era.

New Chapter: Landmark Hospitality Steps In

Five years after the devastating 2007 flood, the Ryland Inn was back. In 2011, Frank and Jeanne Cretella of Landmark Hospitality acquired the shuttered property, planning to restore the historic restaurant and turn it into a destination for dining, weddings, and special events. By October 2012, the restaurant had reopened under executive chef Anthony Bucco.

And the piano was playing again. Restaurant critic Cody Kendall described live piano and bass music accompanying diners, while the renovated Polo Room retained its cathedral ceiling and equestrian paintings. For longtime patrons who remembered the earlier piano bar years, the music offered a familiar connection to the past. On August 2, 2013, The Star-Ledger declared the comeback complete, awarding the restaurant four stars for its food, service, and atmosphere.

But the comeback also signaled a new direction. A special events room was being developed, and plans for a boutique hotel were underway. The Ryland Inn had returned, but its future would increasingly revolve around weddings, banquets, and private celebrations alongside its celebrated dining tradition.

In 2013, a grand ballroom that could accommodate about 300 guests was added, establishing the Ryland Inn as a major wedding and banquet destination. For the owners, private celebrations offered a more sustainable business model than relying solely on fine dining.

For longtime patrons who remembered the piano bar and Shelton’s celebrated restaurant, the change was unmistakable. The Ryland was becoming less about an evening out and more about weddings and special occasions.

Some might call it the beginning of the Ryland Inn’s wedding factory era. Others might call it the business decision that saved a historic landmark. Either way, the transformation that began in 2011 permanently changed the property’s identity.

Today, two New Jersey hospitality groups are helping shape the future of some of the state’s historic restaurants, taverns, and landmark properties. Landmark Hospitality, now operating as By Landmark, was founded by Frank and Jeanne Cretella and has grown into a major hospitality organization with more than 18 restaurants, hotels, and event venues across New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Its portfolio includes the historic Ryland Inn in Readington, Stone House in Warren, the Farmhouse in Hampton, and the Logan Inn in New Hope.

Meanwhile, the newer Celtic Hospitality Group, led by owner Alyssa Cranston and CEO Thomas McAteer, is establishing its own presence in Somerset County. Its properties include the newly reopened Bedminster Tavern, formerly Delicious Heights, Bridgewater Manor, and The Valley at Neshanic. McAteer previously served as chief operating officer of Landmark Hospitality, creating an interesting connection between the two organizations. As these hospitality groups restore, renovate, and reinvent historic properties, an important question emerges: How much of New Jersey’s history is being preserved as these old gathering places find new life?

Do You Like Digging Deeper?

The official National Register of Historic Places nomination for the Whitehouse–Mechanicsville Historic District in Readington Township, Hunterdon County. Its purpose is to identify, research, and document historically significant buildings, properties, and places, establish their importance to the community’s history, and determine whether the district qualifies for recognition on the National Register. Officially listed on March 17, 2015, the district includes the former David Sanderson residence, identified as Site No. 101, which later became the Ryland Inn. For our story, this report provides a valuable historical foundation, helping separate documented facts from longstanding local traditions while preserving the history of the people, buildings, and businesses that shaped the area.

The Whitehouse–Mechanicsville Historic District received state approval and was officially listed on the National Register of Historic Places on March 17, 2015.

Original document:
Whitehouse–Mechanicsville Historic District, National Register of Historic Places Registration Form (123 pages, PDF) December 2, 2014: Listed on the New Jersey Register of Historic Places. March 17, 2015: Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, reference number 15000093.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.