Skip to content

NJ DAR Women Who Save History & A Cemetery in Hunterdon’s White House

. PREVIEW POST (Research Still Underway) but newsworthy… so we published.

What do an old Revolutionary War tavern in Whitehouse, a historic parsonage in Somerville, and a castle in Flemington have in common? The answer might surprise you. Behind each of these historic treasures stands a remarkable group of New Jersey women whose passion for preserving our past stretches back more than a century.

Today, the NJ DAR group is known as the Old White House General Frelinghuysen Colonel Lowrey Chapter of the National Society Daughters of the American Revolution. Yes, that’s quite a mouthful! But there’s a wonderful story behind every part of that name. And as the Mr. Local History Project discovered during the recent historical marker dedication in Whitehouse, these ladies are still making history of their own.

Long before historic preservation became a popular movement, local women were already organizing to protect the buildings, cemeteries, and stories that connected their communities to America’s founding.

Three DAR chapters emerged in central New Jersey, each with its own identity, historic connections, and preservation projects. Over time, they came together to form one organization with an extraordinary collection of accomplishments. Let’s meet the three chapters that started it all.

The General Frelinghuysen Chapter: Saving History in Somerville

Founded in 1896, the General Frelinghuysen Chapter was named for Frederick Frelinghuysen, a Revolutionary War officer who served in the Continental Congress and later represented New Jersey in the United States Senate.

The chapter’s early members gathered at the Wallace House in Somerville, the very building where George Washington established his headquarters during the Middlebrook winter encampment of 1778 and 1779. In 1932, the chapter acquired the nearby Old Dutch Parsonage, another important piece of Somerset County’s colonial history. Recognizing the challenges of maintaining the property, the women eventually transferred it to the State of New Jersey in 1947. They also helped preserve the Watson Cemetery in Hillsborough Township, where General Frelinghuysen himself is buried.

But perhaps the most fascinating story from the chapter’s early years involves a woman named Elizabeth McIlroy. In 1896, at the remarkable age of 101, Elizabeth became a member of the chapter. She wasn’t simply a descendant of a Revolutionary War soldier. She was the actual daughter of one!

Her father, William McIlroy, had served in the American Revolution. Imagine sitting in a room with a woman whose father had lived through the very events we now study in history books. Elizabeth died shortly after joining the chapter and rests today in the Old Somerville Cemetery. Talk about a living connection to history!

The Colonel Lowrey Chapter: The Ladies With a Castle

Meanwhile, in Hunterdon County, another group of DAR women honored Colonel Thomas Lowrey, a prominent Flemington patriot who helped supply the Continental Army.

Lowrey’s buildings housed military provisions and weapons during the Revolution, making Flemington an important location in the American supply network. Those supplies attracted British attention. In December 1776, British Colonel Francis Geary was killed near Ringoes during an expedition into the area.

1873 map of what was known as the New Jersey Turnpike or the Easton Somerville Turnpike, now Route 22.
The Easton Road(s) Marker
part of the White House Historic District

But the chapter’s own history includes something equally intriguing. In 1927, the women received ownership of Fleming Castle, the historic home associated with Samuel Fleming, the man for whom Flemington was named. Despite its grand name, Fleming Castle is not exactly the kind of castle you might find in medieval Europe. Nevertheless, this charming colonial building became a treasure of Hunterdon County.

For nearly eight decades, the DAR chapter maintained the property and used it as its headquarters. In 2005, the building was sold to the Borough of Flemington, ensuring its continued place in the community’s historic landscape. How many local organizations can say they once owned a castle?

Our third chapter brings us to Readington Township and the community of Whitehouse. Organized in 1928, the Old White House Chapter took its name from the historic inn that also gave the community its name.

During the American Revolution, the White House Tavern and its associated buildings helped support Washington’s army. The property was connected with Abraham Van Horne, who helped provide supplies to the Continental Army.

As you walk the cemetery, you can’t help wondering who these people were, how old they were when history called, and what they lived to see afterward. Among them are nine Revolutionary War patriots whose service connected local farms and families to the struggle for independence. Their recorded deaths span 1817 to 1844, placing their burials decades after the fighting ended.

According to the chapter’s history, the property’s large barn held military provisions and even housed Revolutionary War prisoners. The original tavern eventually disappeared, but the historic ground remained.

Some went into service remarkably young. Cornelius Messler was seventeen when drafted in June 1776. Edward Mitchell enlisted at twenty in November 1775. Matthew Adams was 21 when he began a documented enlistment in spring 1778. Captain Richard Stillwell was about 34 when the teenage Messler served under him in 1776. Their ranks brought together young recruits and established adults from the same community.

Two men bring the local story into particular focus. Abraham Van Horne helped supply the army through the White House tavern, which operated as a commissary and forage depot. Washington ordered bread delivered there in July 1777, when Van Horne was about 37. The community’s familiar landmark helped sustain troops moving through New Jersey.

Messler’s experiences show how deeply the war reached into a young man’s life. At 17, he served under Captain Stillwell during the January 1777 fighting at Van Neste’s Mill near present-day Manville. His published biography also describes fighting at Springfield and hauling provisions to Morristown. The young soldier and his captain would eventually share this burial ground.

All nine soldiers survived the Revolution. Their ages at death ranged from 70 to approximately 89, averaging about 80. They had decades to watch the nation they helped establish take shape. Messler and Abraham Van Doren became Whitehouse church elders. As late as 1840, Adrian Johnson, Messler, and Mitchell appeared together among Readington Township’s pensioners, elderly neighbors whose youth belonged to the founding of the country.

Family Donates Cemetery to DAR

In 1931, Harriet Van Horn Traphagen’s family entrusted the cemetery and memorial park to the Old White House Chapter. The gift honored Harriet, her family’s history, and the early settlers and Revolutionary War patriots associated with the property.

Nearly a century later, the DAR continues to care for this remarkable little piece of New Jersey history. Today, thousands of motorists pass the cemetery along Route 22, probably unaware of the stories resting behind its stone walls.

A closer look at the 134 documented burials at Memorial Park Cemetery, also known as the DAR Memorial Park Cemetery in Whitehouse Station, reveals a fascinating picture of life and death in early Hunterdon County. Of those buried here, 71 were female (53%), and 63 were male (47%), a remarkably even distribution. The greatest concentration of recorded deaths occurred between 1820 and 1869, with the 1840s accounting for 39 burials, followed by the 1850s with 24 and the 1830s with 22. Together, these three decades represent nearly two-thirds of the cemetery’s documented burials, highlighting its importance to the local community during the nineteenth century.

Perhaps the most revealing statistics concern age at death. The records show 11 children who died before their first birthday and another 14 between ages 1 and 10, a sobering reminder of the dangers of childhood in an era before modern medicine. Yet the cemetery also tells a story of remarkable longevity. Twenty individuals reached ages 71 to 80, while another 22 lived into their 80s and four reached their 90s.

These contrasting figures offer a glimpse into the hardships and resilience of earlier generations. More than a collection of historic gravestones, Memorial Park Cemetery preserves a statistical snapshot of the families, children, and elderly residents who helped shape the Whitehouse community over generations. These figures reflect documented burial records, not the entire historical population.

In 1995, the Old White House and General Frelinghuysen chapters joined forces. With the eventual addition of the Colonel Lowrey Chapter, the organization brought together generations of preservation experience from Somerset and Hunterdon counties. The result was the Old White House General Frelinghuysen Colonel Lowrey Chapter, NSDAR. The name may take a few extra seconds to say, but it represents something special: three communities, three historic legacies, and a shared commitment to keeping America’s story alive.

Not Your Grandmother’s DAR

Think the Daughters of the American Revolution spend all their time researching family trees and attending formal meetings? Think again.

These women have been collecting supplies for veterans at the Lyons VA Medical Center, supporting local food pantries, recognizing outstanding students, promoting the United States Constitution, and participating in community celebrations. They have even won trophies for their patriotic floats in Lebanon Borough’s Fourth of July parade, complete with colonial costumes and enthusiastic cries of “Huzzah!”

From left to right: DARs Ann Rotunno (Cemetery Committee Chair), Ashley, Catherine Paretti, and Amy Matza. They are nicknamed “the Three A’s.”

In 2020, when the pandemic made traditional gatherings difficult, the chapter came up with a particularly clever idea for a cemetery fundraising tour. They called it “Socially Distanced with the Socially Departed.” Now that’s history with a social twist! That same year, the chapter reported 119 members and more than 3,500 hours of volunteer service. These are women who understand that preserving history doesn’t mean living in the past. It means making the past relevant to the people living today.

On November 15, 2026, the historic DAR Memorial Park Cemetery once again hosted a celebration of local history. The dedication of a new historical marker recognizing the White House Tavern highlighted the property’s Revolutionary War connections and the community that grew around it. The project, involving the Forgotten Victory Trail Association and the William G. Pomeroy Foundation, is another reminder of how local organizations can work together to bring overlooked history back into the spotlight.

For the DAR chapter, it was a celebration on the ground that generations of its members have worked to preserve. For the Mr. Local History Project, it was an opportunity to discover another remarkable organization whose contributions deserve recognition.

Here’s something to think about. Could someone in your family tree have helped establish the United States of America?

Membership in the DAR is open to women age 18 and older who can document their direct descent from someone who provided qualifying service in support of the American Revolution. And you don’t necessarily have to descend from a soldier. Ancestors who provided other forms of patriotic service may also qualify. The chapter welcomes prospective members and can help guide.

Website: https://www.njdar.org/old-white-house-general-frelinghuysen-captain-lowrey-chapter-nsdar.html
Follow them on Facebook – Click Here – Or better yet, join them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.