One thing is for sure: You can guarantee that each of these businesses in New Jersey will have lines out the door and down the block every Christmas Eve. Most are also “CASH ONLY,” so make sure you have planned for all the necessary protocols if you want to put “Jersey’s Best” on the table for the holidays. Mostly tied to butcher shops and bakeries, living here in North Jersey, the Mr. Local History Project team has a few favorites to share. (See the entire list at the end of the post.)
Is your “GO TO” pictured below? In the comments, share with us the best of the best that you can be lucky to get on Christmas Eve.

| Town | Business Category | Business | Street Address |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bay Head | Bakery | Muellers Bakery | 80 Bridge Ave, Bay Head, NJ 08742 |
| Clifton | Bakery | Styertowne Bakery | 1039 Bloomfield Ave, Clifton, NJ 07012 |
| East Hanover | Bakery | Sorrento Bakery | 36 Eagle Rock Ave, East Hanover, NJ 07936 |
| Hackensack | Bakery | B and W Bakery | 614 Main St, Hackensack, NJ 07601 |
| Newark | Bakery | Calandras Bakery | 204 1st Ave, Newark, NJ 07107 |
| Newark | Bakery | Ferraras Bakery | 625 Bloomfield Ave, Newark, NJ 07107 |
| Summit | Bakery | Natales Summit Bakery | 185 Broad St, Summit, NJ 07901 |
| Emerson | Bakery and Pastry Shop | Rispolis Pastry Shop | 23 Emerson Plaza East, Emerson, NJ 07630 |
| Raritan | Bakery and Pastry Shop | Randazzos Pastry Shop and Bakery | 611 US 202, Raritan, NJ 08869 |
| Chester | Butcher and Meat Market | Chester Meat Market | 27 W Main St, Chester, NJ 07930 |
| Cranford | Butcher and Meat Market | Perrottis Quality Meats | 23 S Union Ave, Cranford, NJ 07016 |
| Roselle | Bakery and Deli | Pinhos Bakery and Deli | 1027 Chestnut St, Roselle, NJ 07203 |
| Lodi | Deli and Specialty Foods | Vitamia Foods | 206 Harrison Ave, Lodi, NJ 07644 |
| Freehold | Fish Market and Seafood | Woolleys Fish Market | 655 US Highway 9 N, Freehold, NJ 07728 |
| Lebanon | Fish Market and Seafood | Metropolitan Seafood | 1320 Route 22 W, Lebanon, NJ 08833 |
| Westfield | Fish Market and Seafood | Westfield Seafood | 220 South Ave W, Westfield, NJ 07090 |
| Point Pleasant Beach | Italian Market and Prepared Foods | Joe Leones | 510 Route 35 S, Point Pleasant Beach, NJ 08742 |
| Watchung | Ham and Holiday Meals | HoneyBaked Ham Company | 1549 Route 22, Watchung, NJ 07069 |
Comments
We would love to hear your traditional standing in line just to get a Christmas tradition. Post in the comments below.
Other Historic Jersey Foodie Mr. Local History Research
Related Mr. Local History Holiday Posts
Insights: General Charles Lee’s Capture at Widow White’s Tavern in Basking Ridge & Washington’s Delaware Crossing Impact
Views: 944 December 13, 1776, stands as the most electrifying day in Basking Ridge’s history, when the sleepy colonial crossroads suddenly became the center of the Revolution. At dawn, the… Read More »Insights: General Charles Lee’s Capture at Widow White’s Tavern…
Making That Christmas List Was Not a Click Away
Views: 174 …and some of the ways we’d all look for the best toys to put on our list. In the 1960s and 1970s, a Christmas list was something you… Read More »Making That Christmas List Was Not a Click Away
Basking Ridge Christmas Eve Sing 7PM – Watch on Your TV or Device
ONLINE STREAM: Basking Ridge Christmas Eve Sing on The Town Green at 7pm on Dec. 24th.
Holiday Tradition – Basking Ridge Christmas Eve Community Sing
The town of Basking Ridge, New Jersey, welcomes its 102nd Christmas Eve Sing on The Town Green at 7pm on Dec. 24, 2023. The town’s residents, friends, and guests gather to sing traditional carols and celebrate local history, documented by…
Wreaths Across America – Saturday, December 13
Views: 80 The Mr. Local History Project Volunteers will be at the Basking Ridge Presbyterian Church and the Somerset Hills Cemetery in Basking Ridge this Saturday, December 13, 2025. If… Read More »Wreaths Across America – Saturday, December 13
Widow White’s Tavern Series – A Basking Ridge American History Moment
Views: 250 December 13, 1776, stands as the most electrifying day in Basking Ridge’s history, when the sleepy colonial crossroads suddenly became the center of the Revolution. At dawn, the… Read More »Widow White’s Tavern Series – A Basking Ridge American…
The Candy Cane Man – Basking Ridge’s Own Christmas Eve “St. Nick”
Views: 458 I think I first heard of who I call St. Nick about 20 years ago, gathering on the town green in Basking Ridge on Christmas Eve, as thousands… Read More »The Candy Cane Man – Basking Ridge’s Own Christmas…
The Basking Ridge Christmas Eve Carol Sing – Black River Journal
Views: 355 The editors of the Black River Journal recently reached out to the Mr Local History Project with a simple request. They wanted to help tell the story of… Read More »The Basking Ridge Christmas Eve Carol Sing – Black…
Mr. Local History’s 2025 Advent Calendar of Memorable Toys/Gifts & Their History
Views: 1,988 And on the 25th Day of the Advent Toy History Calendar… Holiday Memories is such great history, and what better way to look back than remembering how Advent… Read More »Mr. Local History’s 2025 Advent Calendar of Memorable Toys/Gifts…
American Board Game History
Views: 452 We all know the feeling. Say the words board games, and something instantly pops into your mind. With the holiday season bringing family and friends together, it is… Read More »American Board Game History
Basking Ridge Live Cam – Mr. Local History’s Beautiful Town Green
Views: 9,986 Yes, there is sound too. You can mute it if you like.IF you just see the link, the stream is offline. Check back later. How’s life in Basking… Read More »Basking Ridge Live Cam – Mr. Local History’s Beautiful…
Vintage Toys Are the Best History Ever – Playing, Collecting, Remembering
Views: 1,439 New Jersey has been shaping America’s toy box for more than a century. It began in Cinnaminson with Samuel Leeds Allen’s 1889 Flexible Flyer sled and in West… Read More »Vintage Toys Are the Best History Ever – Playing,…
Mr. Local History 2025 Holiday Gift Giving Guide / Magazine
Views: 607 If you got the word, you get the head start on the End Of Year Holiday News, Specials, Events, and MLH Stories The magazine is free and our… Read More »Mr. Local History 2025 Holiday Gift Giving Guide /…
Colonial Christmas To Shine Again at Bedminster’s Vanderveer House
The Jacobus Vanderveer House in Bedminster, New Jersey, is celebrating Colonial Christmas, an annual fundraiser event that combines history, tourism, tradition, and Christmas spirit. It offers an array of activities including music, reenactments, crafts, and holiday shopping.
The Exclusive New Jersey Historic Wooden Village Keepsake Collection
Views: 14,619 The MLH Project is proud to be the exclusive reseller of the New Jersey Historic Wooden Keepsake Collection, created by the world-famous Cat’s Meow Village. Made in the… Read More »The Exclusive New Jersey Historic Wooden Village Keepsake Collection
Wearing Lost Jersey Businesses is Fun History
Views: 9,629 Mr Local History loves history with a social twist. In fact, it’s our motto! So we thought how fun it would be to share some of the most… Read More »Wearing Lost Jersey Businesses is Fun History
Keepsake: Basking Ridge Christmas Eve Caroling on the Green
Views: 10,388 The Governor of New Jersey’s Historic Keepsake Village has decreed that a new icon should be added to the New Jersey Historic Wooden Village Collection, expanding the exclusive… Read More »Keepsake: Basking Ridge Christmas Eve Caroling on the Green
SHOP LOCAL – Small Business Saturday is Everyday at Mr. Local History!
Views: 2,675 The Mr. Local History Project is probably the “smallest of small businesses” and needs your support. We have great gifts that bring fun and memorable local history to… Read More »SHOP LOCAL – Small Business Saturday is Everyday at…
Who Brings Their Jersey Village Collectibles out Just for the Holidays?
Views: 1,006 We have been told a terrible rumor. Is it true? Do some people bring out their Jersey Cat’s Meow collectibles only for the holidays? Read on…. Yes, we… Read More »Who Brings Their Jersey Village Collectibles out Just for…
Holiday Greeting Cards are all about Local
Views: 2,662 Join Bernardsville and Basking Ridge as they kick off the holiday season with our Mr. Local History Holiday cards representing the best of the season for the villages… Read More »Holiday Greeting Cards are all about Local
Holiday Tradition: Basking Ridge Fire Company, a Christmas Tree and a Boot
Every year, the Basking Ridge Fire Department erects a locally donated 30-foot evergreen tree on the town green. The fire personnel also decorate the tree which becomes a central piece for the town’s holiday celebrations.





































