Skip to content

History Debunked: Separating Myth from Fact

In honor of America’s 250th anniversary, we’ve been on the road, attending many great speeches and presentations on our country’s history. But one speaker gave an interesting twist, asking the audience about some commonly stated facts that have since been debunked. We thought it’d be fun to share a few that we’ve heard and try to set the record straight.

Is that True Mr Local History Project

So when you’re out at that BBQ, share some new knowledge.

Common Quote or BeliefTrue or FalseHistorical PeriodPerson or SubjectUpdated Historical Understanding
America became independent on July 4, 1776.FALSE1776Declaration of IndependenceCongress voted for independence on July 2, 1776. The Declaration explaining that decision was approved (adopted) on July 4, and the engrossed parchment was signed by most delegates on August 2, 1776, with a few signing later.
The word ‘Independence’ appears in the Declaration of Independence.FALSE1776Declaration of IndependenceThe word “Independence” never appears in the text. The official title is “The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America.” The document declares the colonies to be “Free and Independent States,” but its modern name became common later.
Paul Revere rode alone shouting ‘The British are coming!’FALSE1775Paul RevereRevere was one of several riders, traveled quietly, and likely warned that the Regulars were coming rather than shouting “The British are coming.”
Give me liberty, or give me death!’ is exactly what Patrick Henry said.FALSE1775Patrick HenryHenry delivered a famous speech, but the wording was reconstructed decades later by William Wirt from recollections rather than a contemporary transcript.
Betsy Ross made the first American flag.FALSE1776-1777Betsy RossNo surviving contemporary documentation proves she designed or sewed the first United States flag.
The Hessians were drunk during the Battle of Trenton.FALSE1776Battle of TrentonThe Hessians were surprised because of poor weather, fatigue, and Washington’s careful planning—not widespread drunkenness.
The Revolutionary War ended at Yorktown.FALSE1781-1783American RevolutionYorktown effectively ended major fighting, but the war officially concluded with the Treaty of Paris in 1783.
Everyone supported American independence.FALSE1775-1783American ColonistsThe population was divided among Patriots, Loyalists, and many who remained neutral.
The Liberty Bell rang on July 4, 1776.FALSE1776Liberty BellThere is no evidence the bell rang on July 4. It may have rung on July 8 when the Declaration was publicly read.
John Hancock signed large so King George could read it.FALSE1776John HancockThere is no contemporary evidence supporting this story. Hancock regularly signed documents with a large signature.
George Washington had wooden teeth.FALSE1780s-1790sGeorge WashingtonHis dentures were made from ivory, gold, lead, and human and animal teeth—not wood.
Benjamin Franklin discovered electricity.FALSE1752Benjamin FranklinFranklin demonstrated that lightning is electrical but did not discover electricity.
Washington won because he was a brilliant battlefield commander.Misleading1775-1783George WashingtonHis greatest achievement was preserving the Continental Army through difficult campaigns until victory became possible.
The Revolution was only America versus Britain.FALSE1775-1783American RevolutionThe conflict became a global war involving France, Spain, and the Dutch Republic.
Nobody knows who fired the first shot of the Revolution.TRUE1775Lexington and ConcordThe identity of the person who fired the first shot remains unknown.
Valley Forge was Washington’s hardest winter.FALSE1777-1780Continental ArmyMany historians consider the Morristown winter of 1779-1780 to have been even harsher.
New Jersey was simply the ‘Crossroads of the Revolution.’TRUE1776-1783New JerseyNew Jersey witnessed more than 600 military engagements and became the principal theater of the war after New York.
The Boston Tea Party protesters disguised themselves to fool the British.Mostly False1773Boston Tea PartyThe disguises were largely symbolic, and many participants were recognized anyway.
George Washington wore a white wig.FALSE1770s-1790sGeorge WashingtonHe usually powdered his own reddish-brown hair rather than wearing a wig.
The Declaration of Independence created the United States government.FALSE1776Declaration of IndependenceThe Declaration announced independence. The national government developed under the Articles of Confederation and later the Constitution.

Fun Facts about the Declaration of Independence

Declaration of Independence in Philly Mr Local History
Interesting FactWhy It Matters
Congress voted for independence on July 2, 1776.The vote for independence came two days before the Declaration was approved.
The Declaration was adopted on July 4, 1776.July 4 marks Congress’s approval of the final wording, not the vote for independence.
Most delegates signed the Declaration on August 2, 1776.The famous parchment was signed weeks after July 4, with several delegates signing even later.
The official title is “The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America.”That is the title printed at the top of the original engrossed document.
The word “Independence” never appears in the Declaration.The document declares the colonies to be “Free and Independent States,” but never uses the noun “Independence.”
Thomas Jefferson wrote the first draft in about 17 days.Jefferson completed the initial draft remarkably quickly.
The Declaration was edited by four other committee members before reaching Congress.John Adams, Benjamin Franklin, Roger Sherman, and Robert R. Livingston reviewed Jefferson’s draft.
Congress made dozens of edits before approving the Declaration.About one-quarter of Jefferson’s original wording was removed or revised.
Jefferson’s original draft included a passage condemning the slave trade.Congress removed the passage before approving the final document.
The Declaration contains 1,337 words.It is a relatively short document that profoundly changed world history.
The Declaration contains 27 grievances against King George III.These complaints explain why the colonies believed separation was justified.
The Declaration mentions a higher power four different times.It refers to “Nature’s God,” “Creator,” “Supreme Judge of the World,” and “Divine Providence.”
The Declaration never mentions democracy.It argues for natural rights and government by consent but does not use the word “democracy.”
The Declaration never mentions the Constitution.The Constitution would not be written for another eleven years.
The Declaration never creates a government.Its purpose was to declare independence and explain why.
The Declaration drew on centuries of earlier documents.It was influenced by Magna Carta, the English Bill of Rights, the Virginia Declaration of Rights, and John Locke’s philosophy.
The Declaration was intended for an international audience.It sought recognition and support from foreign nations, especially France.
The first printed copies were produced overnight.Printer John Dunlap worked through the night to print the first broadsides.
Only about 26 original Dunlap Broadsides are known to survive.They are among America’s rarest and most valuable historical documents.
The original parchment has faded dramatically.Years of light exposure caused much of the ink to fade before modern preservation methods.
The Declaration was hidden during World War II.For protection, it was secretly stored at Fort Knox alongside the Constitution.
The largest signature belongs to John Hancock.His signature became so famous that “John Hancock” became slang for a signature.
Not every signer was present on July 4.Several delegates returned later to sign the engrossed parchment.
The Declaration inspired independence movements around the world.Its principles influenced revolutions and declarations in Europe, Latin America, and beyond.
The Declaration remains one of the most influential political documents ever written.Its ideas about equality and natural rights continue to shape democracies around the world.
The Declaration became a model for many later declarations of independence.Historians have identified its influence in the declarations or founding documents of countries including France, Belgium, Greece, Liberia, Vietnam, and many nations in Latin America, among others. Rather than copying its exact words, many adopted its principles of natural rights, popular sovereignty, and the right of a people to establish their own government.
Joel Farkus Speaker Bernards Township Library
Special shout-out to Joel Farkus, speaker at the Bernards Township Library, who inspired us to write this post. Well done, Sir.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.