Skip to content

Haunted Tales From Central New Jersey #3

Believe it or not, the dead are alive in central New Jersey, especially in northern Somerset County. The question is not whether they are real or not, but rather whether they are disturbing or friendly. As we share, The Mr. Local History Project is looking for the public to share their paranormal experiences at the end of this story.

5. Jersey Devil -The 13th Scorned Freak Child – Pine Barrens, New Jersey

The Jersey Devil is one of the most famous urban legends in American folklore, particularly in New Jersey. According to the tale, the creature was born in the early 18th century to a woman named Mrs. Leeds, who was said to have been cursed with a thirteenth child.

Upon discovering she was pregnant with a thirteenth child, she allegedly exclaimed, “Let this one be a devil!“ When the child was born, it was said to transform into a terrifying creature with the head of a goat, bat-like wings, and a long, forked tail.

The newborn quickly flew out of the window, disappearing into the Pine Barrens, a vast forested area in southern New Jersey. Since then, countless sightings of the Jersey Devil have been reported. Locals describe eerie noises in the woods, strange footprints, and glimpses of the creature darting through the trees. Some say it has a blood-curdling screech that can send chills down your spine. Over the years, the legend of the Jersey Devil has become a part of local culture, inspiring stories, films, and even sports teams.

Whether viewed as a myth or a true creature, the Jersey Devil remains a haunting figure, embodying the mysterious and supernatural aspects of the Pine Barrens. But it did get named after New Jersey’s NHL hockey team!


4. Devil’s Tree & The Deadly Caretaker – Liberty Corner, New Jersey

Farmer gone mad – under the spell of the tree – defended the tree with his white pickup truck. Killed his family and burned down his house. His spirit still guards the Devil’s Tree.

If you aren’t afraid of some bad karma, the Devil’s Tree in Bernards Township is said to be cursed. Anyone who disrespects the tree will have harm come to them. The lone oak tree comes with  different legends, including that it was the site of a farmer who hanged himself after killing his family, and anyone who attempts to cut down the tree will find themselves coming to an untimely end.

He has been said to drive a white pickup truck around the area over the hillside grass and drive recklessly towards anyone who attempts to desecrate the tree and the devil portal. Some say that in the winter the ground beneath the tree is free from snow, while a nearby boulder named “Heat Rock” is always warm to the touch, no matter the season, and is rumored to be a portal to Hell.


3. Ghost Portal – Trump National Golf Club, Bedminster, New Jersey

On a tour of the Trump estate, the Estate manager, David Schutzenhofer, invited me to spend the afternoon with the Trump property. David was a great guy and very knowledgeable about the history of the home and some of the people who once lived on the estate.

He showed me around the building once owned by John Delorian and his 4th wife, Christina Ferrara (divorced in 1985). In the 19th century, the area was owned by the Cowperthwaite family. The original farmhouse was one of the biggest in the area for over a century. We shared stories about the history of the property and the area, of which there are many. Then David asked if I wanted to see the ghost portal. I was taken back a bit and looked at him with this quirky smile and said, “Sure, I do.” So he brought me past Delorian’s son Zach’s bedroom and right down a short hallway to a closet door. We’re both standing outside the door, and he says, “Here it is.” I was like…. Okay, now tell me the story.”

Word has it that many guests who have been allowed upstairs at night have actually seen “multiple—up to 3 servers at a time carrying trays from the portal door up and down the hallway into the bar area and sitting room upstairs. They roam, stop, continue to roam, then walk back through the portal door and are gone. No noise, no harm, very well behaved.

I asked to come back again at night when no one was upstairs, and he said sure. I did, and I honestly can say I didn’t see any ghosts, but I twice felt a VERY COLD breeze of air come through my body. You be the judge.

1. Chinqueka, the Chimney Rock Ghost – Bridgewater, New Jersey

There are indeed some local legends and folklore about paranormal activity around Chimney Rock in Bridgewater, NJ. One of the most notable stories involves sightings of ghostly apparitions and unexplained phenomena. People have reported seeing mysterious lights, hearing strange noises, and even encountering ghostly figures in the area.

The Chimney Rock Ghost, also known as Chinqueka, New Jersey, is a local legend associated with the Chimney Rock section of the town in the Bridgewater gap. The story typically revolves around the ghost of a woman who is believed to haunt the area, often described as wearing a white dress. According to the legend Chinqueka met her untimely death at or near Chimney Rock, and her spirit is said to haunt the area. This tale takes us back to the 16th century. Chinqueka, an Algonquin word for Goldfinch, was the daughter of the tribal leader of the Leni Lenape tribe which had settled near Bound Brook in the Raritan Valley.

It has been told that on a hunting trip in the Ramapo Mountains, Chinqueka and the Lenape hunting warriors crossed paths with a Prince from the nearby Manhattan tribe. The two groups continued to hunt in unison and actually became close. The leader of the Lenape tribe became friends with the Prince on the trip and ultimately bequeathed his daughter to Chinqueka. It didn’t seem to matter to the Chief that he had previously bequeathed his daughter to a local Lenape warrior back in Bound Brook. His name was Manassamitt.

When they returned to Bound Brook, the Prince and Chinqueka would often escape the tribe and go for long walks in the First Watchung mountain area and Chimney Rock was a beautiful lookout to visit. But not this time.

While the prince was atop Chimney Rock waiting for Chinqueka, he didn’t know he was being followed by Manassamitt. Manassamitt was so enraged that he had lost Chinqueka, he attacked the Prince, bludgeoning him to death and throwing off the Chimney Rock cliff into the Raritan valley below. When Chinqueka arrived and saw what had happened, her sorrow was so strong that she threw herself off the cliff to her death below.

When word got back to the Manhattan tribe about the Prince and Chinqueka’s deaths, the two tribes declared war that lasted for years. Those who visit the Chimney Rock have noted that there have been ghostly sightings and shrills of screams along with the sounds of a crying woman near the site. Have to admit, I wouldn’t go near that cliff’s edge if I heard such sounds!


1. The Abandoned Hofheimer Grotto and Cemetery – Warren, New Jersey

Nathan Hofheimer emigrated to Warren in 1865, was part of the copper mine industry in Central New Jersey. When the copper mine gave up all the copper it could in the Warren Township neighborhood, Hofheimer filled it with water and surrounded it with a semi-circular, multi-level structure made from rocks pulled from the mine, creating the impressive Hofheimer Grotto & Cemetery. Built in 1915 by Nathan Hofheimer, it was interesting to learn that Hofheimer also made his fortune in the whiskey business, and was one of the first investors of the General Motors Company.

Courier News July 11, 1956

You’ll find the Hofheimer Cemetery southeast of the Grotto where the original home burned to the ground in 1927. The house had been vacant since Nathan’s death in 1921. The Mausoleum, which was totally desecrated with spray paint, and had a collapsed roof. I walked the nearby trails and saw some mounds that looked human-body-sized. One of the most popular legends involves sightings of ghostly figures and strange lights around the grotto, especially at night. Many have stated that it is the ghost of Nathan Hofheimer himself floating around the cemetery at night with a light as the caretaker. Some visitors have also reported feeling an unexplained chill or hearing whispers when no one else is around.

The creepy grotto and pond on what was the Hofheimer’s palatial summer estate. The cemetery has few remaining visible headstones, and many graves may not have markers or have lost them over time. Information about specific burials is scarce, as the cemetery lacks comprehensive records or well-maintained headstones. So who knows who’s floating around here at night!

The Grotto is currently the property of Elks Lodge 885. It IS open to the public and can be found at 99 Bardy Rd, Warren, nestled in the woods on the Elks Lodge property. The Mausoleum was auctioned off for the princely price of $1.00, with the understanding that it be removed within a set period of time. As can be seen, only one granite roof slab was moved. It is said that the cemetery is haunted and a caretaker has been seen at dusk guarding the cemetery.

Local Lore
Beginning in 1911, when Nathan’s son Arthur bought a parcel of land on the corner of Warrenville and Washington Valley roads, family members acquired over 300 acres of farmland at the center of Warrenville. Over the following decade, the Hofheimers built their summer retreat, complete with four mansions, a golf course, horse stables, swimming pools, a family mausoleum, and an imitation European-style grotto on the Middle Brook at what had once been the site of a copper mine. So the question remains: Is Nathan Hofheimer roaming the grotto and cemetery? Let us know your thoughts.

The Haunted Tour Map

BONUS – Dr. Moldenke and His Castle – Warren, New Jersey

One of the most popular ghosts tales from Warren, New Jersey is about the ghost of Dr. Moldenke himself, who is said to haunt the grounds of his former castle area. Visitors have reported seeing a shadowy figure and hearing strange noises, especially near the old laboratory and mausoleum. Some believe that the ghost is still conducting experiments or guarding his beloved castle.

Moldenke Castle, also known as Castle Elisnore, in the Watchung section of Warren, NJ, has a fascinating and eerie history. Built in 1900 by Dr. Richard Moldenke, a metal-lurgist, the castle was modeled after the Moldenke family castle in Denmark. It stood as a grand structure with 35 to 40 rooms, including a laboratory, a mausoleum with 21 crypts, and even a cannon from the Civil War.

The castle was abandoned and fell into disrepair over the years. In 1969, a mysterious fire gutted the building, and arson was suspected due to the strong smell of kerosene and opened fuel oil tanks. The ruins of the castle have since been a source of local legends and ghost stories.

Have a tale to share about the Jersey Horrors in Central New Jersey?
Post in the comments section below.

A collection of ghosts and historic scary tales from around Central New Jersey



2 thoughts on “Haunted Tales From Central New Jersey #3”

  1. Supposedly, Mead Hall at Drew University is haunted. Before the campus Safety office moved to a newly built building, night operator/dispatchers had some “odd” occurances.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.