Top 10 Most Historic Businesses in the Somerset Hills, New Jersey

Whether you’re a banker, national political figure, CEO, or farmer, the Somerset Hills has provided commercial opportunities for centuries. From C. Ledyard Blair and Jackie Kennedy to Secretary of State Cyrus Vance and Charles Pfizer, the Somerset Hills business community has served up commerce in a classic fashion.

There’s no mistake that the Somerset Hills area is rich in long-lasting commerce history. The Somerset Hills region of Bedminster, Bernards Twp, Bernardsville, Far Hills, Peapack & Gladstone has long been one of the most prestigious and historic areas in New Jersey, and they have some landmark businesses to prove it. So which ones have entrenched themselves in the fabric of our communities and built a rich and historic legacy? Which of these businesses have outlasted their competition? Please leave it to us to take it upon ourselves to research and compile what we feel are the top 10 historic businesses in the Somerset Hills.

The criteria for deciding who made the list include the business’s longevity,  significance to the local community, and the rich history of the owners or the property. While it can be debated as to the rank and order of the top 10, each business should be congratulated for its historic longevity and dedicated service while continuing to re-engineer, reinvent, and survive. While our economy struggles again, seeing who’s still here for the next go around will be fun. We applaud their commitment to the Somerset Hills community and thank them for their service to our community. PLEASE DON’T FORGET THEM! They support our community, charity events, baseball programs, and schools, and most are our neighbors. Let the debate begin.

The Top 10 Most Historic Businesses in the Somerset Hills

10 – Meadowbrook Glitter Factory – Bernardsville

Since 1934, they’re quiet, they’re steady. They’ve been at the base of Dead Man’s Hill since there was a Dead Man’s Hill. Family owned and operated, they’ve glittered the world like no one else’s business (cause it’s no one else’s business). A hidden gem in the Somerset Hills. (World leading manufacturer of Glitter)

9. Brush’s Deli (PC Henry) – Basking Ridge

Since the 1860s, give them their props. Whether it was appliances, cigarettes, or the best Sloppy Joe sandwich in town, the general store concept is alive and well at Brush’s Deli. Barbra Brush has been operating Brush’s since 1940. The NY Times quoted, “The humor of a neighborhood bar is evident from the moment one enters Brush’s. A sign over a tray of pennies reads, “If you need a penny, take one. If you need two, get a job.”

No. 8 – Sky Farm Nudist Colony – Liberty Corner

(Nudist Retreat) “America’s First Nudist Colony Est. 1932 –  Celebrated as the only place to catch a nude volleyball game or barbecue, you have to love it when they posted their reason for not wearing swimsuits in the pool – “to prevent the suit fibers from clogging the filter”. No kidding. You have to take your hat off (and everything else) to them to stick to the bare essentials of their business model.

No. 7 – The Bernards Inn – Bernardsville

The Bernards Inn – Bernardsville – (Hotel/Restaurant) – No older operating hotel in the Somerset Hills exists. Classic charm, classic beauty, and a classic mainstay for guests visiting the area. I wish they still had the bowling alley. They celebrated their 100th anniversary in 2016.

No.6 – The Grain House @ the Old Mill Inn

6. The Old Mill Inn Grain House – Basking Ridge – While the structure was first built across the street in 1768, the beginning as an Inn/Restaurant started during The Depression when 50 men were hired to move the barn across the street to its current location. None of the beams or lines of the house changed one bit. Thank William Childs and his family for serving libations and home-cooked meals since the early 1930s. It’s living history. Mr. Local History wrote about the grand 250th anniversary of the Old Mill Inn’s Grain House.

No. 5 – M.J.Neil Heating & Cooling – Bernardsville

M.J. Neil – Bernardsville – (Fuel) While the structure goes back before 1860, MJ Neil has been in business with the same family for four generations. From the day the former owner walked back from lunch declaring he didn’t want to be in the business anymore, it’s been in the Neil’s hands since that bill of sale was signed. July 18, 1918. They officially celebrated their 100th anniversary in 2017.

No. 4 – The Bernardsville News

Bernardsville News – Bernardsville (Publication) – Since 1897 – Others have come and gone, but this publication has been the social, political, and newsworthy voice of the Somerset Hills for over a century. UPDATE: in 2017, the Bernardsville News moved to Randolph and put their building up for sale.

No.3 – Bernardsville Cinema

Bernardsville Cinema – Bernardsville – (Cinema) Since 1913 – Records show advertisements for live shows and theater back to the turn of the 20th century. From little kids to aging couples, while it’s morphed from one screen to three today, it’s still a pillar to the entire Somerset Hills community.

No. 2 – The English Farm – Liberty Corner

English Farm – Liberty Corner – (Active Farmstead) Since 1740 – 8 generations. A continuously functioning working farm in the same spot where Revolutionary War troops crossed with the supporting French troops on their march that concluded in the classic Yorktown victory.

No. 1 – Delicious Heights aka Willie’s Tavern – Bedminster

Delicious Heights / Willie’s Tavern – Bedminster – (Tavern) – Est. 1780. The building was erected in 1780 by Aaron Melick for his son, John, who was returning home from the Revolutionary War. Since that time, it has served as a pub, a polling place, a pool room, a package store, a political forum, a speakeasy, a hotel, and a restaurant. In 1893, Willie Howard came to Gladstone with Charles Pfizer and served as huntsman for the Essex Hunt. In 1898, Willie and his wife, Bertha, upon Willie’s retirement, purchased the Bedminster Hotel, as it was called, for $5,000. The hotel was renamed the “Howard Hotel,” in 1912, the first indoor plumbing was installed. The name has since changed from Willies Tavern to Delicious Heights, where you can still grab a sandwich and a pint today!

Local Historians Speak Out – Believe Me

Not to be accused of personal bias, we wanted to ensure that some of the area’s famous historians had a crack at it, naming the top 3 historic businesses in the Somerset Hills. It’s not like ten was hard enough, but three is an even more challenging task. All three have unsurpassed Somerset Hills history resumes.

A local historian, June Kennedy, was fun to discuss history with. Just get ready to soak it in because she pushes it out. The stories keep on coming. So, June Kennedy chose to weigh in on the discussion. “Given the three, I’d rank them 3. Bernards Inn, 2. Willies Tavern and 1. Grain House. “The Grain House and Mr. William Childs meant so much to the area, and the restaurant you know was once a barn across the street in the late 1700s. There’s just so much history there.”

Another lovely lady, Jean Hill, a local historian in Bernardsville and longtime Somerset Hills area resident, thinks the top three go like this: 3. Willies Tavern, 2. The Grain House, and 1. Bernards Inn. Why the Bernards Inn number one? “The Bernards Inn has been such a wonderful mainstay to the area. I feel overall it’s the most historic.”

And you can’t ask Jean and not ask Marion Kennedy. Marion is another Bernardsville history expert and resident who rates her top three as: 3. Old Mill Inn, 2. Bernardsville Cinema, 1. M.J. Neils Fuel Supply. And why does she choose M.J. Neil as her top pick? “You must see M.J. Neils and talk to David Neil to understand why. He’s the fourth generation family member to work and own the same business at the same location. Don’t ask me why I chose it – it’s just it.”

Honorable Mentions

While the list was being created, a few businesses needed to be mentioned. Fantastic businesses that are also very rich in history. But when you’ve only got spots for ten, we thought it appropriate to say – honorably!

• Millington Quarry – Basking Ridge – Est. 1895. While its hands have changed over the years and the names have changed, crushed stone has still been delivered for over 100 years. But it’s not going to be around much longer. Local historians note that in its time as AT&T employees dominated in the 1970s, the Morris County Crushed Stone Company was the leading employer in the area. Don’t forget what Stonehouse Road is named after. The quarry still exists, but it is no longer active.
• MV Italian Restaurant– Bernardsville – (Eatery/Tavern) Some remember it as Freddies, others as the Old Stone Tavern or Equus Tavern. Whatever you call it, the location has continuously served food and spirits since 1849. Maybe the Parker Tavern ghost stops in for a beverage occasionally.
• Somerset Hills Country Club – Bernardsville – Est 1899 – a quaint private club nestled in the rolling hills of Bernardsville. The club’s logo incorporates the crest of the (English) Duke of Somerset, and the course was designed by A.W. Tillinghaust, who also designed Baltestrol, Winged Foot, and Bethpage Black (US Open 2009). With approximately 200 members, it’s about as private as possible.
• Washington House – Basking Ridge – (Eatery) 1886 – Same looking as the Bank of America building up the street. It had other names and owners, including The Store, Ridge Tavern, and Washington Hotel.
• PJ Koeschlein’sGeneral Store (Krauszers) – Liberty Corner – (General Store) – Est 1901 – Home of the first phone, first car, and other numerous firsts in the area. And it’s been in continuous operation for over a century. If you live in this area (and I do), it’s a mainstay to the area. Look close enough, and you’ll see the Koeschlien’s
• Galloway & Crane – Bernards Twp – Funeral Parlor – Practicing their craft since 1935.
• Peapack Gladstone Bank – Peapack – (Financial Services) – Since 1921, it has been the oldest established bank in the Somerset Hills area. I just hope they don’t need the TARP money.
• Far Hills Country Day School – Far Hills – (Private School) – Since 1929, people have graduated from Far Hills, such as former Governor Christine Whitman.
• Presbyterian Church of Basking Ridge (Religious) Basking Ridge – We thought it was worth mentioning since it’s such a piece of the area’s fabric and a centerpiece to the community. In the business of religion since 1717. And who can’t use a bit of religion in their life these days? Celebrated its 100th anniversary in 2017.

Young Guns Deserving Mention

While you’d think they’ve been in the Somerset Hills area forever, they’ve just created an early entrepreneurial mark on our community in a short period (relatively speaking). We were stunned that some of these businesses are as short-lived as they are. If you have any others yyou’dlike to mention, feel free to post a comment and add your favorite young gun!

• Somerset Grain & Feed – Bernardsville – (Retail Farm Supply)- Established 1945
• Beval Saddlery – Gladstone – Saddlery – Creating some of the best equipment since 1955, starting in Bernardsville.
• Turpin Real Estate – Far Hills (Real Estate Agency) Since 1960 (49 years old)
• AT&T – Bedminster – (Bedminster – Telecommunications) 1976 Move to Bedminster, forever changing the Somerset Hills landscape.
• Pingry School – Basking Ridge (Private School) – Founded 1861 (1983 in Martinsville- looks like Bernards Twp to us) Just hasn’t been in the Somerset Hills long enough.

Special Thanks

Criteria

Special thanks go out to all local businesses that submitted background information and nominations to the T3 Consortium for consideration. In addition, we’d like to thank the Bernardsville Chamber of Commerce, specifically the efforts of Nancy McLure, as well as the Basking Ridge Business Alliance (BRBA) and the Bernardsville Library Spinning History room, which all submitted business suggestions for consideration.

Original Post Date: February 18, 2009
Updated: December 31, 2024

More Business Local History