Foodie

The Official Sandwich of Basking Ridge – What Now?

How often do you get to participate in history? Now you do. There is a battle in the town of Basking Ridge, where the Mr. Local History Project has connected with the town’s oldest deli to battle it out for the right to name the “Official Sandwich of Bernards Township.” Voting has been fierce, and it looks like it’s going to come down to last-minute voters who’ve been debating this for years. Put to a vote by residents, they have spoken!

The “Town Special” Wins Community Vote

Congratulations to Brush’s Deli invention – The “Town Special” which was voted the “Unofficial Sandwich of Basking Ridge” by residents. Pictured here is actually a “SUPER Town Special” with BACON!

After a month of voting, the Town Special has been voted the “official Sandwich of Basking Ridge.” The mouth-watering turkey and Swiss on rye with cole slaw and Russian dressing have been a favorite since they were coined in the 80s. To celebrate this grand proclamation, Mr. Local History has donated a limited number of official Bernards Township flags that will be given away FREE to anyone ordering two Town Specials over the next month. One per customer, please. Stop into Brush’s Deli for all the details and congratulations for over 3 generations of service to the community and the Town Special, the unofficial sandwich of Basking Ridge.

Close Contenders

Two sandwiches have been battling it out since we started. At 25 votes – tied. At 100 votes – virtually tied. 175 votes – virtually tied 200 tied, 240 we had a break and could make a call as we tie the results to our just released Retrospective: Brush’s Deli Serving The Community for Three Generations as the oldest deli in the township.

Down to the wire, there were a number of contenders for the title. One is a breakfast monster, called “The Monster”, a sandwich made for two including double what you’d normally have on a typical breakfast sandwich. The classic sloppy joe sandwich was another contender serving up a triple deck beauty including a combination of turkey and roast beef, Swiss, cole slaw, and Russian dressing on soft rye. And last but not least there’s the “House Special” a combination of roast beef, horse radish mayo, lettuce and Swiss cheese on rye.

Brush’s Monster
Brush’s Sloppy Joe
Brush’s House Special

Voting Results

July 13, 2022

Read about the history of Basking Ridge’s oldest standing deli. Click Here

Retrospective: Brush’s Deli served the community for over three generations

Brush’s Deli served the community for three generations.


Mr. Local History Project

Recent Posts

Get a Bernards Township Flag – MLH Donates 15 to Project Local History Ambassador

Mr. Local History Project will present flags to 5th graders and share the local history…

8 hours ago

Project Local History Ambassador Flags for Students

UPDATE: March 2025 Connecting Bernards Township students to their local history, the Mr. Local History…

8 hours ago

That Great Stone Wall Around the Bernards Township Town Hall – How Many Stones Contest

Picnickers in 1916 in what was known as Owens Woods. Pictured are Dorthy Wing, Jane…

5 days ago

Bernards Township Origins

Bernards Township Asian Community Research Project seeks researchers to help with this important effort. UPDATE:…

5 days ago

Art and History – Looking for Artists To Interpret History to Celebrate NJ250

Joining the America 250 movement - Artists and New Jersey 250! UPDATE: We are looking…

5 days ago

Gotta Love the Irish in Jersey – The History and All the Parades

Quick History - Irish Immigration to New Jersey By the mid-19th century, Irish immigration from…

1 week ago

This website uses cookies.